John Stuart Mill’s other island : the discourse of unbridled capitalism in post-war Hong Kong

Document Type

Book chapter

Source Publication

The cultural construction of the British world

Publication Date


First Page


Last Page



Manchester University Press


Hong Kong, Positive non-interventionism, Laissez-faire, James Clavell, Britishness


This chapter examines Hong Kong between 1945 and 1979 as an imagined space in which a British “unbridled capitalism” could flourish even as Britain itself developed a welfare state “consensus”. Drawing on political pamphlets, novels, memoirs, journalistic accounts, politicians’ speeches, and trade organizations’ papers, it argues that Hong Kong was widely seen by expatriates as a place in which British values survived after having been quashed in a “declining” Britain. At the same time, Hong Kong provided a foil against which neo-liberal think tanks could highlight Britain’s need to revive an enterprise culture. In fact, Hong Kong’s status as a laissez-faire economy was overstated, as the government increasingly intervened in such fields as housing, public health, education, and infrastructure. In addition, this meme depended on assumptions that the Chinese were compulsive workers uninterested in leisure, and that Hong Kong Chinese were politically apathetic, both of which collapsed in the late 1960s. Despite these tensions, this distinct idea of a Hong Kong Britishness provided a cultural legacy that survived the collapse of the “British world”. At the same time, by preserving what were often called neo-Victorian economic ideals, Hong Kong constituted a model to which anti-Keynesian British politicians of the 1970s could point.



Publisher Statement

Copyright © Manchester University Press 2017.

Additional Information

ISBN of the source publication: 9780719097898

Full-text Version

Publisher’s Version



Recommended Citation

Hampton, M. A. (2015). John Stuart Mill’s other island: The discourse of unbridled capitalism in post-war Hong Kong. In B. Crosbie & M. Hampton (Eds.), The cultural construction of the British world (pp.145-164). Manchester: Manchester University Press. doi: 10.7228/manchester/9780719097898.003.0008