Author

Date of Award

11-2026

Degree Type

TPG Capstone Project (Taught Postgraduate Project)

Department

Sociology and Social Policy

Chief Supervisor

Prof. Plamen AKALISKI

Abstract

This study examines how external economic incentives shape villagers’ intrinsic motivation in ethnic ecotourism through the lens of incentive crowding-out theory. It uses a comparative case study based on a most similar systems design to analyse two representative cases: the Longsheng Rice Terraces in Guangxi, mainland China, which operate under a market-oriented “company–farmer shareholding” model, and the Smangus tribe in Hsinchu, Taiwan, which follows a community-based model of “communal land and cooperative management”. The analysis draws on government documents, news reports, academic publications and statistical records. In Longsheng, external incentives such as ticket dividends and subsidies have crowded out villagers’ intrinsic motivation, shifting collective action from cultural stewardship towards economic dependence. In Smangus, by contrast, economic rewards are embedded in traditional Gaga norms and distributed through collective welfare arrangements, which strengthens intrinsic motivation. The comparison indicates that institutional design, particularly the way incentives are distributed and embedded in local culture, is the main factor determining whether incentive crowding-out can be mitigated. The study therefore recommends introducing external incentives cautiously, prioritising institutions that are compatible with local culture, fostering multiple forms of intrinsic motivation and establishing mechanisms to monitor changes in the relationship between incentives and motivation.

Keywords

incentive crowding-out, ethnic ecotourism, intrinsic motivation, comparative case study, institutional design

Language

English

Recommended Citation

Wu, J. (2026). Incentive crowding-out in ethnic village ecotourism: A comparative study of Longsheng and Smangus (TPG Capstone Project, Lingnan University, Hong Kong). Retrieved from https://commons.ln.edu.hk/soc605_stdwork/29

Share

COinS