Melodrama, tears, and life of Oharu
Many of Mizoguchi’s films portray suffering women, but Life of Oharu (1952) may surpass all his others in the depth of suffering portrayed. The film features a young woman, Oharu, who is the daughter of an Imperial samurai. After a brief relationship with a lower class man, her family is exiled from the Imperial court. This event starts a series of misfortunes which, through many episodes, push her down the social ladder and track her moral descent. Ultimately, in her old age, she is reduced to a pathetic, elderly beggar. The film’s tone straightforwardly reflects its subject matter: it is quite sad to watch Oharu systematically destroyed and left with no sense of a brighter future. Yet, other films have portrayed similarly tragic events but fail to move their audience. In this paper, I will discuss various theories of how a film’s narrative structure can affect its ability to generate sadness, and analyze how Oharu arranges its narration in a particularly effective manner towards this end.
Copyright © 2002-2004,16:9. Alle rettigheder forbeholdes. Access to external full text or publisher's version may require subscription.
Frome, J. (2004). Melodrama, tears, and life of Oharu. 16:9 Filmtidsskrift, 2(6), 11. Retrieved from http://www.16-9.dk/2004-04/pdf/16-9_april2004_side11_inenglish.pdf